How to Make a Baseball-Themed Gift Basket That’s Sure to Be a Total Home Run


In the 2021 baseball season, more than 10 billion minutes of Major League Baseball action were watched by fans. This is the first time this has happened on the league’s out-of-market streaming service, MLB.TV.

It’s safe to say that people enjoy baseball. So much so that you probably know someone in your life who is a baseball fanatic.

Show them you appreciate them by making them a baseball-themed gift basket. Not sure how to do this? Keep reading to find out.

Make a Basket

Before you start buying baseball gifts, you need to have a basket to put them in. This is where you can get creative with your gift.

Of course, you can always buy a regular basket online unless you want to make your own.

You can use a bucket, a giant baseball hat, or even a duffel bag to put baseball gifts into. If you are gifting a basket for the holidays, consider the theme of the holiday to help you create something unique.

For example, if it is Easter, you can create an Easter basket with a baseball theme for your baseball lover.

Maybe the baseball lover in your life is an adult. In this case, an Easter basket might not be appropriate. Get creative by putting their baseball gifts into a large novelty beer mug or shot glass.

Find what you can to make the basket itself baseball-themed. You can buy cheap decorations at the dollar store to make something impersonal more personal.

Personalized Items

A popular item to put in a baseball-themed gift basket is a personalized baseball bat. A personalized bat can be treasured for a long time and it can also be used to play baseball.

There are various online stores that allow you to create a personalized bat for your favorite baseball enthusiast. You can choose the color and other important details that make a baseball bat unique to someone.

Other cool personalized items you can put in a gift basket for baseball fans include the following:

  • Personalized baseball sign
  • Personalized baseball water bottle
  • Personalized baseball keychain
  • Personalized baseball ornaments
  • Personalized baseball

If the gift basket recipient is a future baseball player, a personalized sign is perfect for them. This is a gift that will continuously remind them of their passion for the game.

Personalized water bottles are also great for baseball players. They can rep their favorite team or player while playing the game themselves. Long hours outside on the field makes people thirsty so this gift will come in handy.

Quality sports keychains are handmade to allow baseball lovers to show off their pride with their keys. Around the holidays, personalized baseball ornaments are a great addition to a baseball-themed basket.

Baseball lovers can display personal baseballs with pride. It’s a sentimental gift that can also act as decor. Make sure to buy one that comes with a case so they can display the baseball anywhere they’d like.


A baseball gift basket without snacks is no basket at all! Whether going to a game or watching one on TV, every baseball lover is joined with their favorite snacks.

Consider these snack ideas for the basket:

  • Popcorn
  • M&M’s
  • Beef jerky
  • Sunflower seeds
  • Peanuts
  • Corn chips
  • Chex mix
  • Cracker Jacks
  • Big League Chew

If the giftee is of legal drinking age, you can add some of their favorite beers in the basket. Include a baseball bat beer mug or other creative alcohol glasses that they can drink out of.

Maybe even add ingredients to make baseball park hot dogs.

Baseball Glove

Nothing beats getting new baseball gear that can make playing baseball more fun. If the gift basket receiver plays baseball, getting them a new glove will make their day.

Choose a smooth glove made of high-quality leather if you really want to impress a baseball lover. Wilson and Rawlings are widely considered the best baseball glove brands.

The Rawlings Heart of the Hide R2G Series PROR3319-6BC 12.75″ Baseball Glove is a top choice in the industry.

The glove looks good and performs well. The player in your life will enjoy the deer-tanned cowhide lining, redesigned heel pad, and padded thumb sleeve.

Buying a new glove is more expensive than other gifts you can put into a baseball gift basket so the choice depends on your budget.

Batting Gloves

Like a baseball glove, batting gloves are the perfect gift to add to a baseball-themed gift basket. Batting gloves are great for baseball players and those who just enjoy spending time at the batting cages.

Depending on the brand you get, this gift is typically more affordable than a baseball glove. You can find high-quality batting gloves for around $50 compared to a $200 glove.

Again, the gift you decide is best should depend on your budget and the needs of your baseball lover.

The Marucci Blacksmith Men’s Batting Gloves are made with an embroider goatskin palm and extended leather wrap on the index finger. This adds an extra layer of protection.

Authentic Jersey

Does the baseball lover in your life constantly talk about their favorite team and their chances to win it all this year? If so, you probably know their favorite player without thinking about it.

You can add this gift to their basket if this person doesn’t already have a baseball jersey.

Every fan wants to represent their team. You can shop for jerseys online or at sporting goods stores in your area.

An authentic, high-quality jersey can last for years. This might be one of the best baseball gifts to get!


Anyone can benefit from getting sunglasses as a gift whether they play baseball or not. A baseball player can wear them while they try to win games with their team. A nonbaseball play can wear them when watching their favorite team!

Sunglasses can be worn anywhere which is why they are the perfect gift to put in a gift basket.

When picking up baseball shades, there are some things to consider to find the best ones, such as:

  • Frame technology
  • Lens technology
  • Color
  • Brand

Oakleys are common baseball frames worn by players and fans alike. They can sharpen vision perception to allow players to react faster to baseballs coming at them. They are also stylish enough to be worn with various styles and outfits.

Other notable baseball sunglasses you might add to your shopping list are:

  • Nike Show X3
  • Oakley Flak 2.0 XL
  • Oakley Radar EV Path
  • Kaenon Arcata SR
  • Tifoso Vero

Prescription sunglasses are also available in these brands if you can afford to spend a little more on your baseball lover who wears bifocals daily.

Baseball Shirt

The 3/4 sleeve baseball shirt is a staple in the baseball community. This classic and breathable design is also perfect for personalization.

Choose your baseball lover’s favorite color and size. From there, you can buy decals from craft stores and customize the shirt to fit the needs of the giftee.

Even better, you can buy a bunch of different craft decals to allow the giftee to decorate the shirt to their liking. This could act as a great gift and fun bonding activity.

It doesn’t have to be a baseball shirt. You can also buy a plain button-front jersey for customization.

Baseball Tickets

This is the hail mary of all gifts you can add to a baseball-themed gift basket. What’s better than taking the baseball lover in your life to their favorite team’s game?

Baseball tickets are generally affordable depending on where you sit and the popularity of the team and their opponents.

If your baseball lover’s favorite team is playing out of town, you’ll obviously need to spend more on transportation, housing, etc. However, it just might be worth it to see the look on your baseball lover’s face.

If you have a large enough budget, consider adding season tickets to the basket. This only works if you live in the same area where those baseball games are played.

Baseball-Themed Gift Basket Ideas to Try

Learning how to make a baseball-themed gift basket is simple! You’ll want to gather items that you know the baseball lover in your life will love.

Start by buying or building a basket to put everything in. Work your way through this guide to gather ideas on baseball gifts.

Some ideas like personalized novelties, snacks, and baseball shirts are on the less expensive side. If you have a larger budget, consider sunglasses, authentic jerseys, and maybe throw in baseball tickets.

You can’t go wrong with any of these ideas or by coming back to this blog for more tips.